Posted by Teddyrose@1 on June 26, 2012
Posted in Books Read in 2012 | 8 Comments
Henry is a famous writer but it seems that his writing days may be over. Nobody seems to get his latest book at his publishers and they reject it. Meanwhile he still gets a lot of fan mail but one letter really intrigues him. It is from an elderly taxidermist and he has written a play but needs help with it. There is something about the request that transfixes Henry and he goes to visit the taxidermist in person.
He goes there frequently to help the old man finish his play about a donkey and a howler monkey—named Beatrice and Virgil. It is an allegory of the Holocaust. One day Henry invited the man to lunch rather than meet as his shop and it becomes very evident that the neighborhood hates the old man but Henry seems oblivious to it. The book to me was written in a very disjointed way. In fact in it Henry’s publishers tell him his book is too disjointed. Because of this, it took me a long time to get into the story. I kept thinking, life’s too short to waste time on this book, but there was something that made me keep reading.
It did pick up mid-way through and started haunting me when I would try to go to sleep. The ending didn’t help my sleep either, I felt haunted for days. Would I recommend it? Hm.. I’m not sure but I did find it worthwhile for myself. 3/5
Copyright 2007-2010: All the posts within this blog were originally posted by Teddy Rose and should not be reproduced without express written permission.
Your review doesn’t have me anxious to pick this one up. I didn’t love Martel’s other book, so this may not be for me.
Hi Kathy, I didn’t care for his first book either but I thought I would try him again since I won it.
I also recently read this book and didn’t care for this book much at all. It was to disjointed, as you sai and I found nothing came together at all. Forced my self to finish, but never got satisfied by it. I wasn’t haunted by it either, not sure if that is a good or bad thing.
Although Life of Pi was interesting, I wasn’t as big a fan as some. Not sure about this one, but we’ll see!
Jules, it was very disjointed.
Julia, I couln’t even finish Life of Pi.
What did you think about the way Martel posted the Flaubert story “The Legend of Saint Julian Hospitator” within the framework of the novel? I honestly found it to be the most off-putting aspect of the novel. Martel could have just mentioned the story’s title and let his audience find and read the story of their own volition, but instead quoted it in the most repulsive way:
“…very fair of skin…After many prayers she bore a son.
“…great rejoicing…a feast that lasted three days and four nights…”
Personally, I don’t know how Martel could have ever thought this was a good idea.
Interesting premise
Interesting review. Does it compare with The Reader?